Trials that compare clinician schedules

156 trials compared one way of scheduling or staffing clinicians with another, in 44 of the 66 scheduling topics. Each links to its ClinicalTrials.gov record, its papers or both.

An AI model (Claude, made by Anthropic) read each trial against a fixed list of questions, three times.

156

trials that compare schedules or staffing

Of 1,024 studies read

72

randomized people, units or programs

84 used another design

44

of the 66 topics have a trial

Most: Handoffs at shift change, 46 trials

2

posted results on ClinicalTrials.gov

Of the 55 trials with a registry record

The trials

25 of 156 trials, newest first.

  • Assessment and CommuniCation ExcelLEnce foR sAfe paTient outcomEs (ACCELERATE): A stepped-wedge cluster randomised trial evaluating the effectiveness of a nurse-led assessment and handover communication intervention on patient adverse events.

    Rihari-Thomas J, Int J Nurs Stud, 2026

    Wards before versus after a nurse-led package of shift-start assessment, structured bedside handover and nurse participation in ward rounds.

    Randomized by unit or program · 9 hospital units or programs

    Staff: Nurses

    Measured: patient safety

  • Clinical Performance in Critical Care Simulation under Sleep Deprivation: Effects of Power Napping in the Recovery Napping Protocol for Anesthesiologist Performance (R-NAP) Randomized Controlled Trial.

    Schmidt L, Anesthesiology, 2026

    Anesthesia residents after a 24-hour shift given a 30-minute nap opportunity versus quiet rest without napping.

    Randomized · 35 people · France

    Staff: Residents and fellows

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Effect of 12 weeks with a 30-min nap opportunity during the night shift of healthcare workers on early cardiovascular risk biomarkers: the NAPWORK study protocol of a randomised controlled trial.

    Bouchou Y, BMJ Open, 2026

    A 30-minute nap opportunity in a room with a bed versus a 30-minute rest without napping on night shifts, for 12 weeks.

    Randomized · 80 people · France

    Staff: Nurses, Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Effect of implementing an evidence-based clinical practice intra-hospital transport guideline for hospitalized children: a type III hybrid implementation-effectiveness study.

    Li Y, Implement Sci Commun, 2026

    Routine pediatric intra-hospital transfer and handover versus guideline-based transfer with structured handover checklist.

    Before and after a change · 110 people · China

    Staff: Nurses

    Measured: patient safety, education and training

  • Effects of Operational Naps on Blood Pressure and Performance Among Night Shift Workers

    2026

    No nap versus 15-, 30-, 45- or 60-minute naps at 02:00 during simulated night shifts.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 130 people · United States

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Generative Artificial Intelligence Nurse Staffing (GAINS) Study

    2026

    Standard float pool assignment versus AI-guided float pool staffing for nurses, then nurses and nursing assistants.

    Before and after a change · 660 people

    Staff: Nurses, Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staffing and cost

  • Impacts of time pressure during the ICU handover safety check of critical care nurses: A randomised eye-tracking analysis.

    Chau I, Intensive Crit Care Nurs, 2026

    Simulated ICU handover safety checks with or without time pressure and with or without a checklist.

    Randomized · 91 people

    Staff: Nurses

    Measured: patient safety

  • Implementing an emergency nursing framework improves the quality of clinical handover: A stepped-wedge cluster randomised control trial.

    Curtis K, Australas Emerg Care, 2026

    Emergency departments before versus after implementing the HIRAID structured nursing framework, with stepped rollout, on clinical handover quality.

    Randomized by unit or program · 1,533 people · 29 hospital units or programs

    Staff: Nurses, Other staff

  • THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE I-PASS COMMUNICATION METHOD ON NURSE PERCEPTION OF HANDOVER QUALITY IN THE INPATIENT WARD OF WELAS ASIH HOSPITAL, WEST JAVA PROVINCE

    2026

    Nurses using the I-PASS handoff bundle versus nurses continuing the hospital's existing SBAR handover method.

    Compared groups, not randomized · 46 people · Indonesia

    Staff: Nurses

  • Trial of Reduced Working Hours Among Regular Night Shift Workers in Public Health and Social Care

    2026

    Night shift workers' weekly hours cut from 38 h 15 min to 36 h versus matched units keeping standard hours.

    Compared groups, not randomized · 200 people · Finland

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staffing and cost

  • Assessing the impact of a semi-structured intraoperative anaesthesia handoff cognitive aid on surgical patient outcomes: study protocol for a cluster randomised trial.

    Samost-Williams A, BMJ Open, 2025

    Semi-structured electronic health record handoff aid for intraoperative anesthesia handoffs versus usual routine handoffs, by operating room floor.

    Randomized by unit or program · 3,763 people · 2 hospital units or programs · United States

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: patient safety

  • Impact of disclosing a working diagnosis during simulated patient handoff presentation in the emergency department: correctness matters.

    Amano M, Diagnosis (Berl), 2025

    Simulated emergency department handoffs disclosing the working diagnosis at the start versus at the end of the presentation.

    Randomized · 40 people

    Staff: Residents and fellows

    Measured: patient safety

  • Shift Hours' Impact on Fatigue and Tracking of Eye Dynamics

    2025

    The same radiologists tested after a night on call versus after a night of rest.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 40 people · France

    Staff: Attending physicians

    Measured: staff sleep and alertness

  • Structured Handoff Using Intelligent Framework for Transitions (SHIFT) Trial: A Randomized Controlled Trial of AI-Assisted End-of-Rotation Handoff Between Hospitalists

    2025

    Attendings with an AI tool drafting end-of-rotation handoffs versus attendings writing handoffs themselves as usual.

    Randomized · 85 people · United States

    Staff: Attending physicians

    Measured: staff health and burnout

  • Acute effects of a simulated quick return on subjective sleepiness, mood, and cognitive performance: A laboratory crossover controlled trial.

    Holmelid Ø, Chronobiol Int, 2024

    Simulated evening shift then day shift with 8 hours off versus two day shifts with 16 hours off.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 66 people · Norway

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Comparison of 45-min nap versus no-nap during simulated night shift work on endothelial function: a randomized crossover feasibility trial.

    Patterson PD, Pilot Feasibility Stud, 2024

    A 45-minute nap versus no nap during a simulated 12-hour night shift, same participants under both.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 10 people · United States

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Development and Effectiveness of a Standardized Hand-Off Program Using the SWITCH Tool for OR Nurses: A Randomized Controlled Trial.

    Lee JE, AORN J, 2024

    OR nurses using a standardized SWITCH hand-off tool against nurses doing hand-offs the usual way without a tool.

    Randomized

    Staff: Nurses

    Measured: education and training

  • Effects of a work schedule with abated quick returns on insomnia, sleepiness, and work-related fatigue: results from a large-scale cluster randomized controlled trial.

    Djupedal ILR, Sleep, 2024

    Hospital units given shift schedules with fewer quick returns (under 11 hours rest) versus units keeping usual quick returns, six months.

    Randomized by unit or program · 1,314 people · 66 hospital units or programs · Norway

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff injuries, staff sleep and alertness, staffing and cost

  • Impact of 24 h shifts on urinary catecholamine in emergency physicians: a cross-over randomized trial.

    Dutheil F, Sci Rep, 2024

    24-hour shifts versus 14-hour night shifts and a clerical control day in the same emergency physicians.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 17 people

    Staff: Attending physicians

    Measured: staff health and burnout

  • Overtime work of anesthesiologists is associated with increased delirium in older patients admitted to intensive care unit after noncardiac surgery: a secondary analysis.

    Zhao Y, BMC Anesthesiol, 2024

    Patients whose anesthesiologists had worked over 8 continuous hours versus those whose anesthesiologists had not.

    Compared groups, not randomized · 700 people

    Staff: Attending physicians

    Measured: patient safety

  • Performance of Emergency Physicians in the Management of Critical Situations Twenty-four Hours After the End of a Night Shift

    2024

    Same emergency physicians' simulated crisis performance 24 hours after a 12-hour night shift versus with no night shifts in prior three nights.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 40 people · 1 hospital unit or program · France

    Staff: Attending physicians

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Pharmacy Integrated Transitions (PIT) trial: a protocol for a pragmatic cluster-randomised crossover trial.

    Hantouli MN, BMJ Open, 2024

    Pharmacist-led transition program with structured hospital-to-nursing-facility handoff versus usual discharge process, randomized by nursing facility.

    Randomized by unit or program · 1,052 people · 14 hospital units or programs · United States

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: patient safety

  • Resource Optimization in the Intensive Care Unit Setting: A Staff Education and Scheduling Pilot Study to Improve Treatment Decisions and Staff Satisfaction

    2024

    ICU periods before, during and after an education workshop plus optimized nurse scheduling to staff enough nurses per shift.

    Before and after a change · 73 people · 2 hospital units or programs

    Staff: Attending physicians, Nurses, Other staff, Residents and fellows

    Measured: patient safety, staff health and burnout, staffing and cost

  • The effect of a night shift nap on post-night shift performance, sleepiness, mood, and first recovery sleep: A randomized crossover trial.

    Patterson PD, Scand J Work Environ Health, 2024

    A 30-minute nap, a 2-hour nap, and no nap during a simulated 12-hour night shift.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 28 people

    Staff: Emergency medical services

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

  • Circadian misalignment increases 24-hour acylated ghrelin in chronic shift workers: a randomized crossover trial.

    Qian J, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2023

    Simulated night work schedule (circadian misalignment) versus simulated day work schedule in a laboratory, same workers.

    Crossover: the same people or units worked each schedule in turn · 7 people

    Staff: Other staff

    Measured: staff health and burnout, staff sleep and alertness

How the list is made

The studies came from three places: the 443 papers that name a topic and that PubMed lists as trials; the 602 studies on ClinicalTrials.gov whose title or intervention names a topic; and the 42 trials that cite one of nine well-known schedule trials. A paper and a ClinicalTrials.gov record count as one study when either names the other. That made 1,024 studies. When a trial's papers do not give its ClinicalTrials.gov number, each paper can count as a trial of its own.

A trial is in the list when the groups it compares differ in how staff's work is scheduled or staffed: the length of a shift, the kind of call, the rest between shifts, a planned nap, the way handoffs are done or the number of staff on duty. A trial of a drug, a light, a training course or a sleep aid among shift workers is not.

Each study was read three times by an AI model (Claude, made by Anthropic), each time in a separate run, from its ClinicalTrials.gov record and the titles and abstracts of its papers. The questions were the same each time: whether it compares one way of scheduling or staffing with another, which topics, the staff, the design, what it compared and measured, and its size. Every answer carries a quote, and code checks that the quote is in the study's text; an answer stands when two of the three readings give it, so a study is in the list only when two readings put it there. Each study's three readings make three pairs, 3,072 in all. In 2,961 of them (96%), the two readings agreed on whether the study belongs in the list.

No person checked each reading. Instead, 9 studies whose answers were known were set aside before the full reading: some of the well-known schedule trials, and trials among shift workers of a drug, a light or a sleep program. Read the same way, 9 of 9 were put in or left out of the list correctly.

A trial's size is the number of people who took part, or for a trial published only as a plan, the number it plans; when a paper counts staff and patients apart, it is the staff. Whether a trial posted results comes from its ClinicalTrials.gov record. The list does not say which group did better: open the trial's record or paper for its results.

Download the list (CSV)How the data are made and cited

Sources: ClinicalTrials.gov, searched Nov 14, 2026, from data it processed on Nov 13, 2026; we summarized each record and kept only the fields above. PubMed, courtesy of the U.S. National Library of Medicine.