How the counts are made
Every paper count on these pages comes from PubMed, searched on November 12, 2026, and every trial from the trial list. This page says what is counted, how a paper matches a topic, how papers were read to check each count, and how to download and cite the data.
What is counted
Two kinds of count. For each topic, the papers that name it in their title or abstract: these are the counts on the topic pages. And the papers the National Library of Medicine (NLM) indexed under Personnel Staffing and Scheduling, Work Schedule Tolerance or Shift Work Schedule, each paper once: the papers by year.
A paper's year is the year of its journal issue. Its type, such as randomized controlled trial or systematic review, is the one PubMed gives it.
Since April 2022, NLM has assigned its subject headings by software. Heading counts from 2022 on do not compare with earlier years, so their charts end with 2021. Counts of papers that name a topic read titles and abstracts, which the change did not touch, so their charts run to the last full year.
How a paper matches a topic
A paper counts for a topic when its title uses one of the topic's phrases, or its abstract uses them at least twice, counting all the topic's phrases: one passing mention is not enough. For most topics, it must also name health care staff or a hospital, because some phrases mean something else outside health care.
Example: 12-hour shifts
Its title uses one of the phrases, or its abstract uses them twice
- 12-hour shift
- 12-h shift
- twelve-hour shift
- 12-hour day shift
- 12-hour night shift
It also names health care staff or a hospital
- nurse
- resident physician
- physician
- nurse practitioner
- paramedic
- hospital
- and more
All the rules
Words match whole and in order, in upper or lower case, and a hyphen counts as a space, so "12-hour shift" also finds "12 hour shifts". A phrase also finds its plural: "night shift" finds "night shifts". A phrase in quotes, such as "naps", finds only those words as written.
"Weekend effect", for one, also names a pattern in stock prices and in air pollution.
Four topics need the word shift, roster or rota instead of a word for staff: short turnarounds, on-call duty, self-scheduling and schedule fairness.
Ten need only one of their phrases: night float, nocturnists, mandatory overtime, nurse staffing levels, float pools, night physician staffing in intensive care, nurse rostering, physician and resident scheduling, operating room staff scheduling and home visit routing and scheduling.
| Staff group | Words |
|---|---|
| Nurses | nurse, nursing staff, midwife |
| Residents and fellows | resident physician, medical resident, residency, "interns", house staff, junior doctor |
| Attending physicians | physician, surgeon, hospitalist, intensivist, anesthesiologist |
| Advanced practice providers | nurse practitioner, physician assistant, advanced practice |
| Emergency medical services | paramedic, emergency medical technician, emergency medical services, ambulance |
A paper also names health care staff when it says clinician, health care worker or healthcare worker, and a hospital when it says hospital or emergency department.
Three topics also have a PubMed subject heading of their own: handoffs at shift change, shift work of any kind and work schedules of any kind. Their heading counts show on their pages and are not part of their figures.
How the counts were checked
A phrase can match a paper that is not about the topic. So for each topic, 40 papers were drawn at random from those that name it, in all years, and each was read. A count shows only when at least 32 of the 40 are on topic. A topic with fewer than 40 papers has all of them read and needs the same four in five.
The rule each reading follows: A paper is on topic when it studies, reviews or reports on the practice as used for health staff. A paper that uses the phrase with another meaning, or mentions it only in passing, is off topic.
The papers were read by an AI model (Claude, made by Anthropic), given only that rule and each paper's title and abstract. A second reading of 225 of the same papers, made separately, agreed with the first on 219. The draw uses a fixed seed, 20261112, so it can be repeated.
57 of 66 topics passed and show a count.
Show every topic's sample
Staff groups
Each staff group's words were checked the same way: 40 papers that name a topic and one of the group's words were drawn and read for whether the words mean that group at work as health staff. A group's counts show only when it passed.
| Staff group | On topic | Counts show |
|---|---|---|
| Nurses | 39 of 40 | Yes |
| Residents and fellows | 40 of 40 | Yes |
| Attending physicians | 34 of 40 | Yes |
| Advanced practice providers | 38 of 40 | Yes |
| Emergency medical services | 38 of 40 | Yes |
One more check, on the matching itself: night float's phrases found 239 papers by these rules when a single use anywhere counts, and 241 by PubMed's own search for the same phrases, run the same day.
A last check, on the counting itself: the papers were counted a second time, from a copy of PubMed's records as they stood on November 6, 2026, six days before PubMed was searched for these pages. That copy holds all but 64 of the 33,610 different papers in practice-papers.csv. Of the 345 counts behind the topic pages, such as each topic's papers, trials and reviews, 26 came out lower in the copy: 18 of them by 1 or 2 papers, and none by more than 16. And of 200 papers drawn at random, every one had the same year and publication types in both.
Sources and their terms
PubMed
Each paper's identifier, year, publication types and subject headings. Titles and abstracts are read only to match the phrases and to check the counts, and appear in no page or file.
Searched November 12, 2026
MeSH 2026
The names and identifiers of the subject headings.
Searched November 12, 2026
Both come from the U.S. National Library of Medicine (NLM). NLM asks users to acknowledge NLM as the source of the data
, to imply no endorsement, and to keep the data current or say that it is not. The counts reflect PubMed on November 12, 2026, not papers added since.
PubMed and MeSH courtesy of the U.S. National Library of Medicine. NLM does not endorse these pages or Capillary Health.
ClinicalTrials.gov
Each trial's registry record: its number, titles, design, interventions, size, countries and whether it posted results. An AI model read the records with the papers' titles and abstracts to make the trial list. ClinicalTrials.gov asks users to name it as the source, to give the day it processed the data and to say what they changed: we summarized each record and kept only the fields in trials.csv.
Searched November 14, 2026, from data it processed on November 13, 2026
Written rules
Each limit on the rules page is quoted in at most 40 words from its document, with its section and a link. ACGME holds copyright in its requirements and the professional bodies in their guidance, so each is quoted briefly; state laws and regulations are public, and EUR-Lex's legal notice lets the EU's legal documents be reused. Where an official site refuses automated reading, the row names the public copy it was read in. The documents govern.
Read November 13, 2026
Download the data
- practice-list.csv
Each scheduling topic with its group, the phrases papers use for it, the other words a paper needs, its subject headings, guides and tools.
- practice-list.json
The list's date, the matching rules, the words for health care staff and the words for shifts.
- practices.csv
Each topic's papers from 2021 to 2025 and from 2016 to 2020, the change, its papers in all years, the trials and reviews that name it, its sample result and its research grade.
- practice-papers.csv
One row for each paper and topic: the PubMed identifier, the phrase or heading it matched and where, its year and its publication types.
- checks.csv
Each topic's sample under each version of the list: the seed, the papers read, the papers on topic, and whether its count shows.
- details.json
The data release, the versions of the count script and of the list, and the day each source was read.
- README.txt
What each file holds and its columns, the sources and their terms, and how to cite the data.
- rules.csv
Each written limit on clinicians' hours and staffing: who it covers, its words as its document prints them, its section, document and dates, and the SHA-256 of the copy its quote was found in.
- trials.csv
One row for each trial and the topic it tests: its registry number, papers, design, what it compared and measured, the staff it studied, its size, countries and posted results.
- trials.json
The same rows, with the day ClinicalTrials.gov was searched, how many studies were read and the readers' scores.
- references.csv
The key papers on each topic, the ones our guides cite and well-known studies, with their PubMed identifier or DOI and where each came from.
The files hold identifiers, counts, names and titles, never a paper's abstract. README.txt describes every column.
You may copy, change and share the files for any purpose, including commercial use, under the CC BY 4.0 license. Cite them as below, link to the license and say if you changed them. The quotes in rules.csv, each limit in its document's own words, fall under their publishers' terms, not this license.
The CC BY 4.0 licenseCite the data
APA
ConductScience. (2026). Research on clinician scheduling (Version 0.6.0) [Data set]. Capillary Health. https://capillaryhealth.com/data
BibTeX
@misc{conductscience_clinician_scheduling_2026,
author = {{ConductScience}},
title = {Research on clinician scheduling},
year = {2026},
version = {0.6.0},
publisher = {Capillary Health},
howpublished = {\url{https://capillaryhealth.com/data}},
note = {Data set. PubMed searched on 2026-11-12}
}Releases
Each release says what changed. A figure can change between releases when PubMed is read again.
Release 0.6.0November 14, 2026
- Trials: trials.csv and trials.json list each trial that compared one way of scheduling or staffing clinicians with another, by the topic it tests, with its ClinicalTrials.gov number and papers, its design, what it compared and measured, the staff it studied, its size, its countries and whether it posted results. An AI model read each study three times against a fixed list of questions; README.txt says how the list was made and how well the readings held up.
- references.csv: the key papers on each topic, the ones our guides cite and well-known studies, by PubMed identifier or DOI.
- README.txt says searched, not read, for the day a source was searched.
Release 0.5.2November 14, 2026
- The files are shared under the CC BY 4.0 license: anyone may copy, change and share them for any purpose, with credit. README.txt and details.json name the license. The license does not cover the quotes in rules.csv, which fall under their publishers' terms.
- The pages and README.txt call the list's 66 items scheduling topics, not practices. The files keep the word practice in their names and columns. No counts changed.
Release 0.5.1November 13, 2026
- Washington's overtime law, RCW 49.28.140, now links to an official copy on the state legislature's file server, because the law's web page asks programs not to read it. The quote and the limit are unchanged.
Release 0.5.0November 13, 2026
- Written rules: rules.csv quotes each written limit on clinicians' hours and staffing from its document, with its section, its dates and the day code found the quote in a saved copy: ACGME's duty-hour requirements, the EU Working Time Directive, California's nurse-to-patient ratios, the state laws that restrict mandatory overtime for nurses, and guidance from professional bodies.
Release 0.4.0November 12, 2026
- Counts by phrase: for each practice, the papers that name it in their title or abstract, by year, by publication type and by the staff they name, from PubMed read on 2026-11-12. A count shows only after at least 32 of 40 sampled papers, or four in five of a smaller sample, were read as on topic: 57 of the 66 practices.
- The list of practices, version 1.3.0: a paper counts when its title uses one of a practice's phrases or its abstract uses them twice. Versions 1.2.0 and 1.3.0 narrowed the phrases of 28 practices whose samples fell short; checks.csv keeps each version's sample.
- New files: practices.csv, practice-papers.csv, checks.csv, details.json and README.txt.
Release 0.3.0November 12, 2026
- For each year, the papers under the three scheduling headings whose indexing finished on or after April 1, 2022, when NLM moved its indexing to software, read from the same summaries.
Release 0.2.0November 12, 2026
- PubMed read on 2026-11-12: the papers NLM indexed under Personnel Staffing and Scheduling, Work Schedule Tolerance and Shift Work Schedule, each paper once, by year and by publication type, and the papers under the headings of the three practices that have one.
Release 0.1.0November 12, 2026
- The list of 66 scheduling practices in 11 groups, list version 1.0.0, as practice-list.csv and practice-list.json.
Closest prior work
Reviews and counts of research on shift work and staffing. None of them counts the papers on each scheduling topic for clinicians, which these pages do.
Dall'Ora C, Ball J, Recio-Saucedo A, Griffiths P. Characteristics of shift work and their impact on employee performance and wellbeing: A literature review. Int J Nurs Stud. 2016. doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2016.01.007
Shift length, overtime, rotation, breaks and short turnarounds: 35 studies, 25 of them in health care. The nearest in idea, and it covers five of the topics.
Sweileh WM. Analysis and mapping of global research publications on shift work (2012-2021). J Occup Med Toxicol. 2022. doi:10.1186/s12995-022-00364-0
2,328 papers on shift work from 2012 to 2021, by country and keyword. The nearest count, and it does not split the papers by topic.
Hulsegge G, Coenen P, Gascon GM, et al. Adapting shift work schedules for sleep quality, sleep duration, and sleepiness in shift workers. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2023. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD010639.pub2
Controlled studies of changes to shift schedules and sleep, in any industry: 11 studies.
Rivera AS, Akanbi M, O'Dwyer LC, McHugh M. Shift work and long work hours and their association with chronic health conditions: A systematic review of systematic reviews with meta-analyses. PLoS One. 2020. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0231037
48 systematic reviews on shift work, long hours and chronic disease.
Wu QJ, Sun H, Wen ZY, et al. Shift work and health outcomes: an umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses of epidemiological studies. J Clin Sleep Med. 2022. doi:10.5664/jcsm.9642
An umbrella review of shift work and health outcomes.
Morioka N, Ochi M, Okubo S, et al. Citation Network Analysis of Nurse Staffing Research from the Past Two Decades: 2000-2022. Healthcare (Basel). 2023. doi:10.3390/healthcare11233050
A citation network of 2,167 papers on nurse staffing.
Wong IS, Dawson D, Van Dongen HPA. International consensus statements on non-standard working time arrangements and occupational health and safety. Ind Health. 2019. doi:10.2486/indhealth.57_202
Expert statements on working time across industries, from the Working Time Society.
Each paper checked on PubMed on November 12, 2026.